owlectomy: A squashed panda sewing a squashed panda (Default)
[personal profile] owlectomy posting in [community profile] 25book_pwd

Josh Berk - The Dark Days of Hamburger Halpin

Will Halpin, who is deaf and starting his first year of mainstream schooling after years of attending a school for the Deaf, has the usual anxieties about starting at a new school, fitting in, making friends, being befriended by the school's biggest dork. When one of his classmates dies on a field trip to a coal mine, he suspects foul play and -- along with his dork friend, and with assistance from his ex-girlfriend Ebony -- tries to solve the murder.

This book was a real pleasure to read. Will is delightfully snarky about the problems of accessibility (terrible captions on TV, teachers who spend their time talking with their faces to the chalkboard so it's impossible to read lips) and also a normal teenage boy (who gets a crush on the police sign language interpreter). I was a little concerned when Will made his decision to attend mainstream schooling because he didn't feel political about his deafness in the same way that his classmates did. But I think it's honestly characterized -- Will comes from a hearing family, and his father isn't fluent in ASL, and his longing to fit in is believable; Ebony feels differently and the book doesn't come off as judging either her or Will for their choices.

Ned Vizzini - It's Kind Of A Funny Story

Overachieving Brooklyn teenager Craig checks himself into a psychiatric hospital after making plans to jump off the Brooklyn Bridge. Vizzini himself spent time in a psychiatric hospital as a teenager. The book is based on his experiences, and rings true to me; the other people in the ward aren't portrayed in a way that's sensationalistic or mawkish. There's an instance of transphobia close to the beginning that left a bad taste in my mouth, but it's a tender story and a keen depiction of the weight of depression that's hopeful without being dishonest. (Has been made into a movie, which I haven't seen.)

Paul Griffin - The Orange Houses

The intertwined lives of a veteran of the Iraq war, a Somali immigrant, and a girl with hearing loss, all living in the Bronx. This was beautifully written, but alas! Do we really need more books where getting hearing aids is a metaphor for letting people into your life? It's not as bad as it sounds -- the book acknowledges, at least, that hearing aids aren't a perfect solution -- but I think this gets filed under "People with disabilities are not your metaphor."

Date: 2010-11-04 11:25 pm (UTC)
trouble: Sketch of Hermoine from Harry Potter with "Bookworms will rule the world (after we finish the background reading)" on it (Default)
From: [personal profile] trouble
Thank you!

May I suggest a small editing thing? When you look at the post straight on, you can't see the titles of the books because they're only in the cut tags. Could you edit>

Thank you!

Date: 2010-11-13 05:08 pm (UTC)
ajnabi: cartoonic photomanip of my face (with some body) against a colourful patterned background (Default)
From: [personal profile] ajnabi
I don't think The Dark Days of Hamburger Halpin is actually such a great portrayal of a character who is deaf. I didn't actually read much of the book because I was so turned off it after reading just a few pages, where there is this portrayal of deaf people (Will) as being able to lipread to the extent of understanding everything people are saying on a crowded bus. As a deaf person, I think that's a really problematic assumption, and feeds right into the "disabled people with superpowers" trope. It's not really very true to life. Then again, I wear hearing aids so maybe my lipreading abilities aren't as up to the mark. Still, I have a hard time believing that the author of the book, who is a hearing person, thought about this assumption enough. It seems from your description that the book gets better later on, or something-- I mean, you've pointed out some good things about it. Maybe I should've kept reading. I don't know. Just wanted to point this out, though, hope that's okay.


Reading Challenge Community: Disability

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags